vasveritasB
Actually U.S. courts make a distinction between “streaming” which is temporary and require a connection for every repeat viewing and “downloading” which stores more permanent version that can be watched without an internet connection.
The YouTube ToS allow you to stream videos. They restrict downloads. If you break that, your “cached stream” isn’t legal to begin with. It’s like going into a store giving free samples and taking a box full. You have to follow their rules, or the legal system may rule against you.
Not that it realistically matters for personal local copies. Who knows, there can be a possible fair use exemptions in certain cases.
If you have a Managed Switch with VLAN capabilities, then your new proposed idea and layout make sense.
Your current setup kind of looks like it’s double NAT. Which is not great. You want the Protectli router to be the first device after the Arris Surfboard modem. Have the modem be in only modem/bridge mode. We do not want to use the Arris as a router.
The TrueNAS gods say to leave HDDs plugged in and spinning.
The current way to store digital data is as “living data” with backups. Data only exists if it’s constantly verified to exist. You can’t verify an unplugged HDD. Of course, you need a 3-2-1 backup system, and have to continually verify those backups as part of the living system.
The magnetic platters in a HDD are actually decently reliable. Sure a cosmic ray or error may flip a bit, but that’s why we have backups and redundancy elsewhere in the system. That flipped bit won’t actually damage the hardware.
The real concern with HDDs is that they mechanically wear out and break. They stop spinning. The motors malfunction, the lubricants dry up, the metal bearings wear down, etc.
TrueNAS says the most dangerous time in a HDDs life is when it is spinning up or slowing down from a stop. This gives the most mechanical stress on the HDD. They says it’s better to leave them powered and spinning 24/7 than to unplug them or despin them.
Mikrotik CSS610-8P-2S+IN - $200
8x Gigabit PoE-out ports and 2x 10 Gigabit SFP+ ports.
Miktrotik CRS328-24P-4S+RM - $500
24 port Gigabit PoE with 4x 10Gbps SFP+ ports.
The most important part of a Frigate NVR is the Coral Edge TPU. As long as you can secure one, you’ll be set. The USB version is easiest to use, since it doesn’t require installing drivers and most PCs will have a USB 3 port.
All the processors are good enough for a small NAS and NVR.
I wouldn’t buy a PC without SATA ports or an expansion slot. If you go the mini-pc route, where would your store your HDDs? An expansion slot would let you one day add an HBA card for more SATA connections. By default, it looks like all those motherboards have limited SATA connections. The 7080 Tower says it has 4 SATA connections, but only 1 of them looks like its the full speed SATA3.
You probably want to run all of that on bare metal in containers with Docker or Kubernetes.
Containers let you easily share resources between them, because they all share the same kernel. VMs are harder to share hardware resources with, as you’re finding out.
I was not sure if I should run a LXC container for each docker, or have a single LXC with everything (exception xrdp / XFCE). I don’t know what would be good practices…
LXC is a container. I don’t think you would want to run Docker inside LXC. That’s running a container inside a container. I’m a noob though.
Normally, you run one app per container, or one set of apps per container if they are closely related. You could run all the Plex suite apps inside a single LXC container and Windows alongside it in Proxmox. Or you could run each app inside their own LXC container.
Alternatively, you could run them all in individual Docker containers on bare metal Ubuntu, but not have the ability to install Windows or other OSes.
I use TrueNAS (ZFS) over Unraid because I wanted maximum data reliability. I needed a system with high integrity that I could deploy on multiple computers for backups. Unraid takes less planning and is more forgiving on hardware selection though.
TrueNAS, Unraid, and Synology DSM are all software RAID solutions.
OpnSense is the way to go. It has a good web UI. It’s robust, featureful, and has wide and growing deployment.
Pfsense is mired in controversy, they attacked their peers, and the owners are not honest. The open source Opnsense project had to appeal to the WIPO to force Pfsense to give them their named domain after Pfsense squatted on it and posted inflammatory messages. They aren’t great stewards.
Windows is okay to start. There’s nothing wrong with putting Plex on there, sharing some folders, and having a little server.
You can get more performance and more features for running Linux though. It’s more reliable and you can get more help, because that’s the tool people use. There is a learning curve though.
For a storage server, Linux works well as a NAS (Network Attached Storage). It supports SMB, which is the protocol Windows uses to share files. A Linux server will be able to share files with a Windows PC.