All those student protests on the US seem to be about stopping their universities from supporting the Israel government. But supporting a foreign government is not a normal thing for a university to do, why do they do it?

Is there some educational or research resource they get?

You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments View context
10 points

I think we would need stats before making that first conclusion. Iā€™ve seen a lot of favorability polls of Israel amongst Jewish people, but not sure Iā€™ve ever seen an explicit ask for Zionism or its definition. Iā€™m sure itā€™s out there, but I wouldnā€™t expect the OP to take that for granted without a source.

Your second sentence is arguably correct, but lacking a lot of context and really not presented from a neutral standpoint like the other commentor and I were trying to strike. I think when people are looking for raw information, itā€™s fair to provide that with as little bias as possible, especially on a heated current issue. And fwiw, I likely agree with you on that issue.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Yeah Iā€™m Jewish so this isnā€™t a new issue to me. Zionism is viewed as a fascist ideology by a lot of Jews, there for I think its unneutral to say afluent Jews are why universities are invested in Israel. Iā€™m being as neutral as possible, these are the facts as I know them and I wouldnā€™t trust an poll on this matter done now, personally. The fact that Israel was formed by America after ww2 and has been used as a political and military base for America since. Wikipedia has multiple articles on it.

permalink
report
parent
reply
7 points

All kinds of ideologies are viewed as fascism by all kinds of people, but thatā€™s not a source. Just because you yourself are Jewish does not mean you have an understanding of Jewish people as a whole. If you want to assert something about Jewish views on Zionism, you need to provide a real source. It also doesnā€™t tie directly to your followup with ā€œaffluent Jews are why universities are invested in Israelā€. Why would one follow the other at all?

I also know what Israel is and how it was founded. Your wording this time is much more palatable! ā€œPuppet stateā€ has connotations that I agree with, but would not say if I was trying to be neutral. On a different thread, I think thatā€™s entirely fair. Again though, when people ask for raw info, I think itā€™s only fair to provide that from as neutral a standpoint as possible.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Out of the loop

!outoftheloop@lemmy.world

Create post

A community that helps people stay up to date with things going on.

Community stats

  • 182

    Monthly active users

  • 114

    Posts

  • 2.4K

    Comments

Community moderators