These people are why communists are seen as a joke.

Anyway, to answer their question, I’m joining the Red Army.

You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments
11 points

Without further context, this kind of thing just seems to me like an exercise to get people to imagine a better future. And remember, some people are very stuck in a mindset that a better future is not possible and that the current way is inevitable and always has been.

I also disagree with this framing:

These people are why communists are seen as a joke.

I don’t think communists generally are seen as a joke, first of all. In my experience, the detractors tend to either frame them as frightfully efficient villains or woefully inefficient idealists. But even the most vicious anti-communist rhetoric seems to acknowledge on some level that communists have been impactful historically, even if that rhetoric frames it as a negative impact. There may be a distinction here between communists and communism, where the 2nd is more what’s framed as idealism and the 1st as the villainy.

Second, the wording here is “leftist commune” not “communist society”. Those who use “leftist” to describe themselves, at least in the US cultural context where this might have derived from, can range from “I want universal healthcare” to, well… ultras. There is a lot of ignorance and newness to communism within that, and being a little naive about how things are going to go isn’t necessarily the same as having firmly held views that insist we can “jump from how things are now to fully automated luxury gay space communism within a year, if only people push hard enough on being principled and not revisionist.”

permalink
report
reply

Shit Ultras Say

!shitultrassay@lemmygrad.ml

Create post

A community to post all the funny things Ultras sometimes say.

Created after the Jan 2023 merger of all Shit X Say communities.

This section includes Leftcoms, Anarchists, Trots, Hoxhaists, and Maoists.

MLs are not ultras.

Patsocs, by popular vote, belong in Shit Reactionaries Say

Community stats

  • 16

    Monthly active users

  • 150

    Posts

  • 1.2K

    Comments