7 points
A patch contains more than the changes: it contains the commit message. In open source projects, and in particular in CVE fixes, the commit message can indeed be quite descriptive. It needs to be!
You’re still right, though. But I like to think professionals are able to verify the changes with the high-quality commit message—possibly in less time than investigating the issue themselves.
1 point
How did they submit changes to only one file? Did they not write a test for it? Sounds like a dodgy patch if it doesn’t have a test
