In that case, why do the notes only sync when the devices are on the same local network?
I’ll install the app later to see what actually is going on, as this makes little sense to me.
EDIT: from their website:
No server, no gatekeeper: peer-to-peer sync on local networks
But from their FAQ:
Anyone can get started with Anytype, free of charge. If you self-host your data, Anytype is and will always be free to use. For those who use our backup services, you can use Anytype up to 1GB of storage for free. If you need more, please contact us.
So in other words: it’s not actually (only) p2p, you can use your own devices with p2p, but they also offer a centralized cloud (which they host) for those who do not want the hassle.
Sounds slightly misleading, but all is fine if they properly warn the user in the app.
EDIT: Also, it would be incredibly scammy if they took money for hosting other peoples notes on your devices, so I’m glad that that is not the case. :D
Details: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36802263
It’s not an account you create in a classical way using a server. It’s locally generated data wallet ( we need it for encryption and sync). We talk via on-boarding that your wallet will be synced, and that your data is encrypted only with the key generated on your machine. It’s for people who don’t want to mess with self-hosting. If you want you can make your build from GitHub, disconnect sync, or just self-host yours. This way our promise works.
Thank you. I’ve been looking at their self hosting documentation, which appears to still be a centralized solution, just under your ownership.
The way they handle accounts is rather nice, nothing new, you see it in Joplin and the likes, but it is definitely better than having an unencrypted account on a company-owned server.
