Comment by iAmTheTot@kbin.social on Baldur's Gate 3 is PC Gamer's highest scoring game in 16 years. Here's why

It’s been a long time since we’ve been this excited by a new PC release.

I’m currently sitting about 7/10, personally.

While not the sole reason for the lower-than-most’s score, one critique at the forefront of my mind right now is that the animations are atrociously janky. I am constantly pulled out of my immersion during dialogues by character animations that are robotic, glitchy, or just downright counter to what I’d expect my character to do.

The animation may be not the smoothest but I think the facial expressions are great

Eehhh I don’t know, some of the facial expressions are the worst. The camera often cuts to my character with a brain dead stare or some over the top weird smirk.

Be like me and go Dark Urge backstory. I can’t tell if the animation I just saw was jank or intentionally creepy. Really elevates the immersion.

Yeah I get what you mean, IMO there’s a mix of well captured body language and sometimes wonky facial animations, they probably acted some dialogues and just used some other standard animations for some other characters

Agree about the player custom character during dialogue. The facial animations are terrible considering the face options are predefined. Other characters though look great IMO. Not TLOU2 level face capture but fantastic for an isometric RPG

I do wish our characters felt more alive. The NPCs are phenomenal and it feels weird seeing ours with a blank stare.

Kinda works better with the less-humanoid models like Dragonborn, not as immersion-breaking since you don’t expect human in the first place.

I love the expressions of my self-indulgent gith bard. A bit exaggerated at times but she is a bard and it works so well.

My character is a ranger who basically lives in the woods far away from people and is horribly socially awkward, so the slightly wonky facial animations have actually been perfect for her.

I can’t make the spoiley thing work.

But I had an NPC in act 3 whose eyes kept doing weird spinny things. Both eyes would suddenly snap to me, then one would spin off again. And another NPC who kept … flipping inside out.

Yeah, that’s what I’m suggesting. It’s almost like review scores are subjective. I think the game is good, but not great. I have a lot of QoL nitpicks, my partner and I have run into many multiplayer bugs, the dialogue choices are often 0 or 100 with no in between, I find that animations during cut scenes very subpar, and the combat is good but not great for me.

Larian: Seven? Silly Lemmite, you just don’t understand what I’m doing, do you? The downvotes will only be passing, you should survive the process.

I think, even if you deeply love that specific jank, this game is only an 8/10 currently. As more people get farther in the game, they realize that what was amazing at first kind of falls apart in the later acts, with a truly atrocious ending and tons of cut content. Maybe with definitive edition it will hit a 9/10 but the increasing illusion of choice as the game wears kind of prevents it from being a 10/10. Still a great game but it definitely suffers and is a shell of what it could have been late game.

All things BG3!

Baldur’s Gate 3 is a story-rich, party-based RPG set in the universe of Dungeons & Dragons, where your choices shape a tale of fellowship and betrayal, survival and sacrifice, and the lure of absolute power. (Website)

Spoilers

If your post contains any possible spoilers, please:

Use the text [SPOILER] at the beginning of your title, do not include any spoilers in the title.
Use the appropriate spoiler markup to conceal that content in the body of your post.

Thank you!

Baldur's Gate 3 is PC Gamer's highest scoring game in 16 years. Here's why(www.pcgamer.com)

Baldur's Gate 3

!baldurs_gate_3@lemmy.world

All things BG3!

Spoilers

Community stats

Community moderators