I have been having this debate with multiple western leftist whom I vigorously despise, and it was about people who commit crimes against humanity, and it is very simple really in my point of view people who did unhuman acts (light upholding apartheid, genocide, cleansing, starting an international War) are by definition unhuman. Really simple actually they have took the humanity away from people and used that as an excuse and they sacrifice their own humanity in The Pursuit of that goal therefore morally at least these people should be counted as dangerous animals or the malaria or whatever unhuman living creature who is causing us mass suffering and death. On the other hand you have the Western liberal who think that they are leftist simply because they don’t care if gay people fack, and these people directly benefit from the unhuman acts that their leaders commit, so they turn and blind eye to it or at most say that they are bad people who should be jailed, jail for Bush or Clinton or Kissinger or Putin or whoever does not solve the problem, you talk a lot about prison reform and how it is cruel what you have not seen the other angle which is that these people physically cannot pay back for their crimes within a million lifetimes, I don’t really care about your personal moralities and bullshit that you say to be the most moral in the room restorative justice cannot occur because these people have committed such crimes that they have left the boundary of restoring what they have done, to the point of being unhuman. When people understand that there is no way that would have been taken from them would be restored they want Justice in any way shape or facking form, including leaving all morality aside and just severely punishing those who have committed these unhuman acts.

You can moralize but for me as a person who lives in Iraq when I hear what people would want to do to George Bush or jog Biden or Barack Obama or whom ever I hear the most descriptive forms of torture, and the reason for that is that these people have actually came to to moral clarity, because the forms of brutal killings and torture that they would want to commit are the same as those who have been committed by these unhumans, when restorative justice fails, when there is no way shape or form your oppressors can be punished that would actually restore what they have been breaking you break their stuff in the same way, but in such subject, where these people have violated your right not to be tortured and not to be killed and not to be humiliated the retaliation must not be lesser than the pain that they have put upon every single person that they have violated their rights of. Do not f****** come to me with your Lefty morals or your Western human standard saying that war criminals and unhuman actors should be not tortured or should it be not brutally murdered, These people are not human.

You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments

what part of torturing them is justice and how does that do anything besides making whoever does it a torturer?

i don’t mean that i care about the suffering of monsters, i care about what it makes us if we do monstrous things.

killing is fair game of course, although if you have enough infrastructure and institutional power to do something else and make them clean literal shit off of the ground with their bare hands instead you should.

permalink
report
reply
1 point

I can easily explain to you why torture, and it’s basically because it with alleviate the feelings for those who have been wronged, when Saddam got murdered by the American state people were not satisfied they needed him to suffer as much as they have suffered which is in the eyes of those who have suffered Justice enough. Ignoring the victims just because you can moralize from a far away place how they should act is not material thinking, you again sadly moralize the wrongness that have been inflicted upon people and them wanting to wrong them back, you would say I want Elon Musk and Jeff bezos to work in a factory or a genitarial job, that is you taking a revenge upon them from the same kind of wrongness they have wronged you

permalink
report
parent
reply

i haven’t moralized yet. i want to know how anything being described is justice?

how is their suffering justice? The justice component of putting the oligarch to work in a factory is that the factory work actually contributes to society, not to force bezos to piss in bottles for the rest of his life. Puyi should’ve had the right to a street sweepers’ union.

killing them isn’t even about justice or punishment, it’s about preventing them from continuing to do harm.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Will again you are stepping at the point the point is that he justice in torturing and killing them is that it would bring satisfaction to those that they harmed

permalink
report
parent
reply

politics

!politics@hexbear.net

Create post

Protests, dual power, and even electoralism.

Labour and union posts go to !labour@www.hexbear.net.

Take the dunks to /c/strugglesession or !the_dunk_tank@www.hexbear.net.

!chapotraphouse@www.hexbear.net is good for shitposting.

Do not post direct links to reactionary sites.

Off topic posts will be removed.

Follow the Hexbear Code of Conduct and remember we’re all comrades here.

Community stats

  • 1.4K

    Monthly active users

  • 2.1K

    Posts

  • 19K

    Comments