I think this is a good read to learn about what tabs and tabstops really are regardless of whether you agree that tabstops should be at different positions per line or with the controversial idea of using proportional fonts (this would work with monospaced fonts too).
I will open the comments with the most obvious negative. A lot of people avoid tabs altogether and only use spaces because it is difficult to adjust tabstop positions (the technical term for tab width in this context, see the article) and you want everyone to have the same viewing experience or at least be able to customize it properly if the source uses tabs. One common argument for tabs is that you can modify the tabstops, but it is difficult enough or impossible in enough tools that some people who agree this is good still prefer spaces. What Elastic Tabstops is proposing is not just relating to tabstops (which are poorly supported sometimes as just mentioned) but also proposing an entirely new way to render them. The arguments against tabs in general are only amplified because so few tools would properly display them. The article mentions this was first proposed in July of 2006. Next month that’s going to be 17 years. Still no tools support this out of the box to my knowledge. There is sadly too much collective inertia behind traditional tabstops.
All that said, I have a soft spot for this concept and would really love to see it catch on.
In some of my personal code I liked to have used it (in very specific circumstances, like having many similar-sized parameter declarations e.g. protobuf), but as you said the lack of support means that a lot of code formatters simply trim unnecessary spaces so they never stick around.
What’s more, I am still yet to find a consistent rule about when to apply this kind of formatting - the example in the article shows one for method args but it just doesn’t look good at all. Key-value lists (like maps) might be a good place to use it, but if one key ends up being very long you have a ton of unnecessary space, so I would need to “group” together similar-length keys to make it aesthetically pleasing:
const map = {
foo: 1,
bar: 2,
bazbar: 3,
// I don't want the keys above to be spaced to match this key
someExtremelyLongKeyname: 4
}
Yeah, I personally don’t like aligning key value pairs all the time (maybe rarely I do). The most compelling example is putting a tab before end-of-line comments. Also it would make tab delimited CSV files render more easily.
Thanks!
That’s pretty cool, although personally I’m not a fan of the things this solves. Comments after statements offer no benefit over simply commenting on a line before or after, except maybe keeping the line count the same. And defining your method like:
func methodName( int x
I prefer to write as:
func methodName(
int x
Seems like the project could use a VSCode version, too.
