From Mastodon https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/110588848407336816
First they came for /r/pics … now Reddit are coming for the individual personal subreddits
Quite some years ago I’d realised that amongst the problems with using Reddit as a personal blogging space (my avatar here is a relic of that, if you’d not put the two together) was that I do not in fact have any permanent claim to that space.
Reddit’s previous policies of moderator re-assignment bothered me. The policies apparently instituted September 2022 and being rolled out aggressively in recent days … have not weakened my concerns.
And, checking in now, I find a day-old modmail to /r/dredmorbius, a subreddit which only ever was my own personal posts with comments from a few friends, and about 1,000 subscribers … has received a notice to reclaim by /u/Modcodeofconduct, screenshot attached here.
I have not abandoned the sub. I had closed it in protest of Reddit’s continued failings and war against its volunteer moderators and general community.
And I will not go quietly.
#Reddit #FuckReddit #ModCodeOfConduct #RedditStrike #RedditBlackout
I signed on here at Lemmy.world on the eve of the blackout. I haven’t been using Reddit since and I couldn’t be happier about it.
I will say, that while I like Lemmy (despite its bugs and all that), it severely lacks stupid GIFs and videos, from interestingasfuck, damnthatsinteresting, PublicFreakout, aww, etc.
Maybe that’ll come, but I doubt it.
i actually find the lack of moving stuff refreshing. All the platforms are moving to short addictive video. Reddit wasn’t like this in the beginning, either.
Well, the great thing about the fediverse is you can actually block out things you don’t like, permanently, unlike on Reddit.
I think more content the better, generally speaking. Of course there’s communities I’ve already blocked from my feed even with the little available currently.
This happened to my ~770 people subreddit r/ntfy too. They really lost their marbles, didn’t they? I turned it back to “Public” out of fear that they’ll delete my Reddit account. I fear even “Restricted” won’t stop them. So instead, I’ll manually delete or lock new posts and direct them to the Lemmy instance. I may assign another dummy mod account too and unassign myself. Maybe that’ll give me a way to close the sub in the future.
Ha. I guess thinking ahead is my trade :-) I’m a Principal Engineer, and much of my job is to think about how a software architecture will look in a few months or a year from now. I often say “It’s very lonely living in the future all the time”, because people usually think about their current project and current task, not what’s ahead of them that far out.
Sorry, I ramble. :-)
Off-topic, but I love ntfy! It’s super easy to use to send notifications from a script or program anywhere
Manually deleting posts leads to them reinstating them (I think they set it up botstyle to reinstate posts from subs where mods have been warned). Editing your posts to directing to Lemmy instances leads you to being given a warning, your post being reinstated from earlier versions and then you’re kicked off of your own sub and get a shadow ban alternatively 7 day lockout.
My personal subs that have been private for ages recieved messages saying they will inform me of “further steps” if I refuse to open them up.
One of them is /r/[myRedditUsername] that I use as a kind of scratch pad that I can access anywhere (I’ve since self hosted a wiki) that they are demanding I open up. Like seriously, no one would ever be interested in whatever is there.
They can get fucked. I deleted all of the posts and comments on all of my accounts and requested GDPR requests on all of them. reddit can get fucked.
I have a feeling they’re cracking down on personal subreddits due to their own loophole in the upcoming change to NSFW content. If I interpreted everything correctly, Mods still get to see the full range of NSFW content, meaning seeing NSFW content even in subs that they aren’t a Mod in, whereas regular Reddit users are restricted.
In any case, I find it ironic that they talk about the duty of being a Moderator with such importance, and yet Mods aren’t even paid, AND… it’s quite a common thing that many subs have wildly corrupt Mods. I’ve no joke been PERMANENTLY banned from certain subs for criticizing a movie, a recent episode in a TV show, etc, and I wasn’t even a member of the sub for more than 24 hours. Like, ok, maybe I’m being a bit more harsh in my criticism than others, but when did it become a crime to have an opinion?
you’d think with the recent news they’d be more cautious about sinking to such depths
I was thinking a slow, wheezing, gasping, flailing scramble as they try to figure out how to deal with the deluge of bots previously handled by mods.
“your content is ours, we will do with it as we please, kindly fuck yourself”
I seriously cannot believe what a heavy hand reddit is taking. That IPO threat must be hurting A LOT of wallets right now. This is the flailing desperation of a dying animal, imo. Idk if reddit will actually “die” but I can’t see any healthy and vibrant community existing after this. I just hope they don’t target Lemmy instances with under-handed “subterfuge”
Idk if reddit will actually “die”
I think it depends on us users. If we can make a community work here in the federated space well enough to draw users then reddit might really go away.
But if they manage to kill off 3rd party devs, APIs and etc quickly before these alternatives are baked enough to work for their users and these existing federated tools aren’t good enough – then they’ll just maintain via the network effect.
This is the flailing desperation of a dying animal
I guarantee they did the math and the site will continue. Sure, a small percentage will leave. But they know from user metrics the vast majority of users will remain. They can find mods who will fall in line.
The site will continue, but the content will never be the same.
I guarantee they don’t know how to do that math. There’s no way they’ve factored in the human element. Humans are just too unpredictable
Ordinarily I would disagree, assuming that they must be privvy to data that no one else is and are making carefully calculated decisions.
But with the way that Reddit leadership just continued to make misstep after misstep throughout this whole debacle, when all they had to do was just say/do nothing and wait for everything to blow over, I can only assume their corporate strategy right now is 100% improvised and not calculated.
Almost all subreddits signed up for just a 2-day protests and were going to return to normal after that. It was only because of how Reddit/spez acted in the wake of all this that they’re experiencing the resistance they are now.
