Excellent essay from Coyne and Maroja that picks apart six widespread examples of biology being corrupted by (often well-intentioned) ideology.

1 point

Hmmmm what are your thoughts on this? I thought it was interesting and very opinionated. The authors are definitely clear on their stance. I’ll admit, I skimmed bits and read others, but it felt more like this essay was comprised of things they just wanted to get off their chest and not a means to try and sway any detractors. Which maybe was the point, but it left me wanting.

permalink
report
reply
1 point

It’s certainly opinionated, polemical even. I would encourage you to read it in its entirety and follow some of many links they’ve included to make their case. I myself have subjectively noticed the same changes in science journalism over the last decade that the authors are highlighting, particularly in SciAm.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Skeptic

!skeptic@lemmy.world

Create post

A community for taking a critical look at pseudoscience, quackery, and boldfaced BS.

“A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence.” ~ David Hume

Things we like:

• Thoughtful discussion
• Humor
• Civility

Things we don’t like quite so much:

• Trolling
• Low-effort comments and posts
• Personal attacks
• Spam
• URL shorteners

Carl Sagan’s Nine Precepts of Skeptical Thinking:

  1. Confirm the reality (independent of the status quo).
  2. Encourage debate on the evidence by proponents of all points of view.
  3. Avoid appeals to authority.
  4. Recognize that there is always more than one hypothesis.
  5. Do not cling to a hypothesis simply because it is yours.
  6. Attaching a numerical quantity is key to discriminating hypotheses.
  7. In a chain of argument, all the links must work—not just most of them.
  8. Everything else being equal, the simplest explanation is the most likely.
  9. Proposals that cannot be proven or shown to be false do not have much scientific value.

Suggested Fediverse Communities

RFK Jr. Watch @lemm.ee - Tackling misinformation being spread by antivaxxer politician, Robert F Kennedy Jr.
DebunkThis @lemmy.world - an evidence-based community for debunking misinformation and dubious claims.

Community stats

  • 438

    Monthly active users

  • 99

    Posts

  • 626

    Comments