16 points
Gabe was in the office during the Scranton Strangler police chase (assuming that was the real strangler that got caught).
6 points
Toby believed that he sent the wrong person to jail. So according to him, that wasn’t the real strangler that got caught.
6 points
Gabe goes on to work at Hoolie and then later at The Pied Piper compression start-up. As weird as he is, he never displays any violent or murderous behaviors. I think we can dismiss him as a suspect.
5 points
Gabe doesn’t have the wrist strength the strangle anyone. Also he’s too fat, nobody will like him if he’s too fat.