2

In the same bin(lemmy.film)

posted
*
by
Avatar
King Mongoose@lemmy.filmM
in
Avatar
moviesnob@lemmy.film
2 comments
hidereport

I was having a conversation with my attorney the other day regarding cinema (specifically violent cinema) which left me slightly perplexed. Would you put A Clockwork Orange (1971) in the same bin as The Devil’s Rejects (2005)? From my POV, that’s like putting Rosenquist’s F-111 in the same category with an ambulance chaser a personal injury lawyer billboard.

Side-note: the linked Roger Ebert review of Kubrick’s A Clockwork Orange amuses me as I would have guessed that of all people, the co-author of the screenplay of Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, he would have at minimum understood if not outright championed Kubrick’s 1971 release. The other amusing thing about his review is that I would have written a very similar critique instead for movies like, say, The Devil’s Rejects!

Photo: Stanley Kubrick, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sort:
HotTopControversialNewOld
Avatar
Ph666xSky@lemmy.film
1 point

Please don’t make me agree with Roger Ebert. Both have artistic merits, but sometimes I’d rather avoid re/watching unpleasant scenes for the sake of being artistic.

permalink
report
reply
Avatar
King Mongoose@lemmy.filmOPM
1 point

sometimes I’d rather avoid re/watching unpleasant scenes for the sake of being artistic.

Yeah, I get that, believe me. Where we part company is you saying “both have artistic merits.”

permalink
report
parent
reply

MovieSnob

!moviesnob@lemmy.film

Create post

A community to discuss, debate, and celebrate the history of cinema, emphasis on—but not exclusively—the groundbreaking, avant garde and experimental, with a healthy dose of irreverence instead of the usual navel-gazing that usually surrounds cineastic appreciation.

Community Rules

  1. “All is fair in love and war” but keep it witty or, at minimum, intelligent. If you can’t do either, keep walking. This community’s administrators will not abide simpletons nor bullies.

  2. “Franchise picture” fans and similar ilk, be forewarned: you are open game to be verbally flayed in this public square. Did you not see the name of this community?

  3. There may will be occasionally adult subject matter (NSFW)—such is the nature of the beast. While it is not the scope of this community to purvey nor condone extreme or gratuitous sex or violence, neither subjects are necessarily condemned when in context with the subject matter at hand. It is also not the scope of this community to discuss only adult themes; how else could one discuss Fleming’s The Wizard of Oz (1939) or Donen/Kelly’s Singing In The Rain (1952)?

  • It is suggested you do not subscribe if you are highly sensitive to either subjects.

  • It is strongly suggested that authors of submitted posts mark NSFW content as such. Err on the side of doubt.

  1. All opinions expressed are strictly of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the moderators of this community nor the administrators of this instance (lemmy.film).

Logrolling

!animation@lemmy.film

!filmsframes@lemmy.world

!filmnoir@lemmy.film

!horrormovies@lemmy.film

Community stats

  • 1

    Monthly active users

  • 61

    Posts

  • 109

    Comments

Community moderators