Avatar

Glowstick

Glowstick@lemmy.world
Joined
0 posts • 349 comments
Direct message

The people who are against the concept of free will say that because you have innate desires for food sex and entertainment, that you have no choice to not act upon those in a desires and therefore any delusion that you carry about the choices that you make being done of an entirely unencumbered and Free Will are false.

That’s not the argument against free will. The argument is just that there’s a physical process to every thought in your head. When you think of a tree, inside your brain a specific pattern of neurons and chemical messengers activate which is what creates the thought of a tree.

When you’re consciously deciding whether to eat a donut or a salad, a specific pattern of neurons and chemical messengers are the mechanism by which that decision process is occurring. The pattern of neurons and chemical messengers happening in your brain is the physical mechanism that is performing the decision making process.

There are no thoughts outside of the ones generated by your neurons and chemical messengers. The pattern of neurons and chemical messengers IS the thought that you’re thinking. Your brain (and the thoughts that occur within it) is a physical object that obeys the laws of nature, the same as all physical objects do.

permalink
report
parent
reply

The older i get, the more the past feels like not so long ago. When i was a kid, the decade before i was born seemed like it was wildly in the past. But now as an adult i feel like even the early 1800s isn’t really that long ago. I think part of this is from my mind expanding over time, but i also think part of it is media doing a better job of showing what the past was really like

permalink
report
reply

I didn’t do what you said. Did you read the links?

permalink
report
parent
reply

I’m not. Did you reply to the correct comment?

permalink
report
parent
reply

Huh, TIL. In general society I’ve only ever heard of trolls being male

permalink
report
parent
reply

Neither of those are pejoratives, they’re just the words for your positions

https://www.askdifference.com/natural-vs-supernatural/

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps

Everything you just wrote in your followup reply here continues to fit into those categories as far as i can tell.

permalink
report
parent
reply

But where does your desire and capacity to do that thing come from? It arises from the physical arrangement of neurons/hormones/etc. in your brain and body

permalink
report
parent
reply

Interesting to know, thanks. But how is that any different than for example a troll as it pertains to men?

permalink
report
parent
reply

What if you never had it and never can have it because its not a havable thing

permalink
report
parent
reply