Reviews are extremely lazily done and about game modes. The game modes have seen minimal development since the emergence of ultimate team, and people are justifiably unhappy with that.

Literally not one major outlet is evaluating the actual simulation of the sport, which very clearly has massive investment from year to year and sees serious improvements to complexity and fidelity in each instance, with stagnation only coming when it hits the wall of what console hardware can do.

I’ve seen football simulator. It might maybe be competitive on physics with decade ago Madden, but even that’s generous. If you just want a vehicle for franchise mode it might work for you, but if you want to play football it’s just not close. Madden isn’t perfect as a football sim either, because the physics of football are insanely complex, but there’s nothing out there that’s better than “kind of close to a decade ago” technically. You’re much more likely to make something tolerable leaning into the discrepancy and making an arcade-y NFL Street knockoff, and that isn’t there either.

So you think they should pay more than twice as much than they currently are?

Madden isnt worth $70 a year. Let alone the $156 you seem to be suggesting.

Huh, WoW’s gotten very expensive. FF14 is about €11.