There are plenty of people who are interested in socialism, but if they show up to a socialist org and get called a cracker they’ll leave
I don’t think that’s a real scenario that’s worth worrying about. Where are these socialist orgs that these people are going to show up at and be called crackers right away? Its silly. That’s why I’m making light of it, because this is just an unserious concern
I’m not sure the trolley problem nor Russel’s Teapot are legitimate either; I think the value is in the very clear and specificity of the thought experiment.
(unless thought experiments are bourgeois decadence, if so I will show myself out…)
(unless thought experiments are bourgeois decadence, if so I will show myself out…)
No, but they can very rapidly fall into idealist question-begging, though it is worth noting that the prompt you are giving this comparison to is not clear enough to be a useful thought experiment even by liberal standards. It is just a hazy hypothetical.
(unless thought experiments are bourgeois decadence, if so I will show myself out…)
I got some bad news for you there lol
Where are these socialist orgs that these people are going to show up at and be called crackers right away?
There are some pretty weird Maoist groups out there…
It doesn’t happen in real life because in person everyone understands that you don’t insult people you’re trying to work with.
“I can’t imagine people saying this face-to-face” is a sign that we should ask why we’re saying it at all.
It’s not that i can’t imagine it. Its that it just doesn’t doesn’t happen. Its a made up concern
that’s absolutely true, but im pretty sure the commenter was talking about the site