archived https://archive.ph/0lnCy
We’re quick to mock. Let’s watch closely. We are always at risk of underestimating our opponents.
I mean a miracle could happen, but given that they spent two months without achieving a breakthrough and wasted something like 30% of western equipment already even according to western media, it’s pretty unlikely that they’ve now come up with some magic formula for success. Either way, once this burns out, things are going to clear up a lot I suspect.
I don’t think it’s about miracles. It’s about intelligence. I guarantee that the US lacked the intelligence it wanted on Russian capabilities and part of this entire conflict has been about trying to draw more Russian capabilities out into the open so they can be assessed. The US has so much materiel, so much intelligence gathering apparatus, so much ability to hide their capabilities. I think it’s feasible that the US could wait out any opponent in any conflict. The worst thing for all of us would be for the US to fundamental change the state of play, and therefore I think we need to remain skeptical of our own assessments of the ground truth and look for as much evidence as possible of being incorrect. Otherwise we’re going to get blindsided if it turns out we’re wrong.
We obviously can’t dismiss different possibilities, but everything we’ve seen over past two years indicates that US is not having much success. I disagree that US can wait out Russia here because US is increasingly seeing lack of political will to keep going. It’s worth noting that exact same thing happened in Vietnam and Afghanistan where US was forced to pull out in the end when the cost of the war got too high. The cost of keeping Ukraine going eclipses those conflicts.
US also has much tougher logistics situation than Russia, and this I would say is the biggest factor. Russia can just ship weapons and ammunition by rail while the west is not able to disrupt that in any way. On the other hand, US has to ship stuff across the ocean and through multiple countries only to have much of it blown up once it crosses the Ukrainian border.
There’s also nothing magical in terms of what Russia is doing. They have artillery dominance that they use to great effect. They depleted Ukrainian air defence, and now Russian aviation operates with impunity. They use drones to hunt Ukrainian armor. And finally, they have massive mine fields that are effectively impassible.
There’s been no evidence over the past two years to indicate that US has some ace up their sleeve, but I guess we’ll see soon.
Interesting point. I hadn’t really considered that a US goal, but they very well could be using this conflict in order to assess Russian military capabilities.
Oh good, the Spring Counteroffensive has started just in time for checks watch August.
If they managed to lose millions upon millions of dollars in equipment, nevermind all the lives lost, during their probing operations, we are going to see some truly catastrophic losses now that the full counteroffensive has begun. Given the rate they are going through materiel, I expect them to be fielding trebuchets in the near future.
Seriously though, I can only hope it is shut down so quickly that casulties are kept to a minimum.
Oh good, the Spring Counteroffensive has started just in time for checks watch August.
It’s actually 9D chess, they were referring to Spring in the southern hemisphere which begins in September. It was all a ploy to confuse the Russians with a bunch of dead Ukrainian personnel and wasted tech.
The counteroffensyiv, as I like to call it.
