You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments View context

I’m not interested in proactively suppressing Nazis, as that would make us no different than them.

No, the people who suppressed nazi sympathizers during ww2 are not the same as people committing the holocaust. Nazis weren’t bad just because they targeted their political enemies. I would recommend reading blackshirts and reds and then the economics and class structure of german fascism.

The authority vested in democratic leaders is ephemeral enough that it is the only desirable form of authority. At the end of the day, it’s the people who rule, not their leaders.

All these “authoritarian” socialist societies had democracies. They are more democratic than any western democracy. Look at how Cuba’s family code was drafted before it passed by referendum.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

No, the people who suppressed nazi sympathizers during ww2 are not the same as people committing the holocaust.

The Allies were fighting a war against the Axis powers. While the Nazis rounded up civilians for all kind of reasons, including political views.

We aren’t in a civil war in America right now. There is no basis to take action against modern fascists outside of the numerous acts of domestic terrorism they commit. Rounding up fascists solely based on their political views make us like the Nazis and is unbecoming of any free society.

All these “authoritarian” socialist societies had democracies.

Not the USSR, China, or North Korea which is what I was referring to by authoritarian communists.

permalink
report
parent
reply

We aren’t in a civil war in America right now. There is no basis to take action against modern fascists outside of the numerous acts of domestic terrorism they commit. Rounding up fascists solely based on their political views make us like the Nazis and is unbecoming of any free society.

People who are trying to start a pogrom on trans people, Jewish people, etc should be prosecuted actually, regardless of whether they’re actually successful. You can’t wait for the nazis to win before you crush them, by that point it will be too late.

Not the USSR, China, or North Korea which is what I was referring to by authoritarian communists.

What about these countries governments are different structurally from Cuba’s government?

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

People who are trying to start a pogrom on trans people, Jewish people, etc should be prosecuted actually, regardless of whether they’re actually successful. You can’t wait for the nazis to win before you crush them, by that point it will be too late.

Two wrongs don’t make a right. If we go that route we are going to become the thing we are trying to prevent.

What about these countries governments are different structurally from Cuba’s government?

Rather than a difference in government structure, I would point to a difference in leadership. I personally believe Castro really did believe in socialism and had the best interests of the Cuban people at heart. As great as that is, a system of government that depends on the benevolence of its leaders is not one I want to live under.

permalink
report
parent
reply